Used Cars under $500 per month for Sale in the Greater New York Area

799 Preowned vehicles for sale in the Metro New York area with monthly payments below $500. Search by payment, bodystyle, engine type, or drivetrain.

Your Location

Filters

Metro New York Secondhand Used Vehicles with Payments Under $500 / Month

Customize Payments

Click the + Customize Payments button to tailor displayed auto loan payments to your preferences and credit rating. Our estimated payments assume great credit, $0 down, and encompass state taxes, as well as typical DMV and dealer document fees. Display more accurate payments by adjusting factors such as your state of residence, credit score, down payment, and trade-in value versus trade payoff. Get started now!

State
NY
Credit Score / Avg. Rate
781-850 / 7.13%
Max Payment
$0.00
Down Payment
$0.00
Trade Value
$0.00
Trade Payoff
$0.00
Bad Credit Used Car Loans
Preowned 2022 Subaru Forester Sport for Sale
2022 Subaru Forester Sport

⇩ View Seller Description

This low mileage second hand 2022 Subaru Forester Sport AWD SUV under 22,000 miles, cvt transmission, and 23 MPG, 2.5L gas engine is for sale right now below $26K at Habberstad BMW in Huntington Station, NY. ...View More Details

Sales Price: $25,250
Est. Payment: $473.30 / 72 months @ 7.13% APR
+ Expand Car Loan Details
Mileage: 22,268
Location: Huntington Station, NY
Preowned 2023 Hyundai SANTA FE SEL for Sale
2023 Hyundai SANTA FE SEL

⇩ View Seller Description

This low mileage certified preowned 2023 Hyundai SANTA FE SEL AWD SUV under 5,000 miles, automatic transmission, and 23 MPG, 2.5L gas engine is for sale right now under $26K at Island Hyundai in Staten Island, NY. ...View More Details

Sales Price: $25,680
Est. Payment: $481.31 / 72 months @ 7.13% APR
+ Expand Car Loan Details
Mileage: 5,103
Location: Staten Island, NY
Preowned 2023 Hyundai SANTA FE SEL for Sale
2023 Hyundai SANTA FE SEL

⇩ View Seller Description

This low mileage certified second hand 2023 Hyundai SANTA FE SEL AWD SUV below 9,000 miles, automatic transmission, and 23 MPG, 2.5L gas engine is for sale right now below $26K at Empire Hyundai of New Rochelle in New Rochelle, NY. ...View More Details

Sales Price: $25,687
Est. Payment: $481.44 / 72 months @ 7.13% APR
+ Expand Car Loan Details
Mileage: 9,361
Location: New Rochelle, NY
Preowned 2025 Honda Accord SE for Sale
2025 Honda Accord SE

⇩ View Seller Description

This low mileage used 2025 Honda Accord SE FWD sedan below 3,000 miles, cvt transmission, and 23 MPG, 1.5L gas engine is for sale right now below $26K at Hyundai of 110 in Farmingdale, NY. ...View More Details

Sales Price: $25,500
Est. Payment: $477.96 / 72 months @ 7.13% APR
+ Expand Car Loan Details
Mileage: 3,417
Location: Farmingdale, NY
Preowned 2023 Hyundai TUCSON N Line for Sale
2023 Hyundai TUCSON N Line

⇩ View Seller Description

This low mileage certified preowned 2023 Hyundai TUCSON N Line AWD SUV under 23,000 miles, automatic transmission, and 23 MPG, 2.5L gas engine is for sale right now under $27K at Sansone's Route 1 Hyundai in Avenel, NJ. ...View More Details

Sales Price: $26,759
Est. Payment: $501.42 / 72 months @ 7.13% APR
+ Expand Car Loan Details
Mileage: 22,640
Location: Avenel, NJ
Preowned 2020 Subaru Forester Sport for Sale
2020 Subaru Forester Sport

⇩ View Seller Description

This below average mileage used 2020 Subaru Forester Sport AWD SUV below 67,000 miles, cvt transmission, and 23 MPG, 2.5L gas engine is for sale right now under $23K at Habberstad BMW in Huntington Station, NY. ...View More Details

Sales Price: $22,400
Est. Payment: $487.76 / 60 months @ 7.13% APR
+ Expand Car Loan Details
Mileage: 66,863
Location: Huntington Station, NY
Preowned 2023 Hyundai SANTA FE SEL for Sale
2023 Hyundai SANTA FE SEL

⇩ View Seller Description

This low mileage certified second hand 2023 Hyundai SANTA FE SEL AWD SUV below 13,000 miles, automatic transmission, and 23 MPG, 2.5L gas engine is for sale right now below $26K at Millennium Hyundai in Hempstead, NY. ...View More Details

Sales Price: $25,997
Est. Payment: $487.22 / 72 months @ 7.13% APR
+ Expand Car Loan Details
Mileage: 13,018
Location: Hempstead, NY
Preowned 2024 Honda HR-V Sport for Sale
2024 Honda HR-V Sport

⇩ View Seller Description

This low mileage second hand 2024 Honda HR-V Sport AWD hatchback under 40,000 miles, cvt transmission, and 23 MPG, 2.0L gas engine is for sale right now below $26K at Curry Hyundai in Cortlandt Manor, NY. ...View More Details

Sales Price: $25,995
Est. Payment: $487.18 / 72 months @ 7.13% APR
+ Expand Car Loan Details
Mileage: 40,298
Location: Cortlandt Manor, NY
Preowned 2023 Hyundai TUCSON SEL for Sale
2023 Hyundai TUCSON SEL

⇩ View Seller Description

This low mileage certified preowned 2023 Hyundai TUCSON SEL AWD SUV under 18,000 miles, automatic transmission, and 23 MPG, 2.5L gas engine is for sale right now under $25K at Hyundai City of Bay Ridge in Brooklyn, NY. ...View More Details

Sales Price: $24,670
Est. Payment: $462.50 / 72 months @ 7.13% APR
+ Expand Car Loan Details
Mileage: 17,966
Location: Brooklyn, NY
Preowned 2020 Chevrolet Traverse LT Cloth for Sale
2020 Chevrolet Traverse LT Cloth

⇩ View Seller Description

This average mileage preowned 2020 Chevrolet Traverse LT Cloth FWD SUV below 74,000 miles, automatic transmission, and 23 MPG, 3.6L gas engine is for sale right now below $20K at Genesis of The South Shore in West Islip, NY. ...View More Details

Sales Price: $19,996
Est. Payment: $476.14 / 54 months @ 7.13% APR
+ Expand Car Loan Details
Mileage: 73,567
Location: West Islip, NY
Greater New York Area Cities with Used Cars for Sale Below $500 / Month
Metro New York Area Counties with Used Cars for Sale Below $500 / Month